Carrie Marshall is a writer, journalist, broadcaster, songwriter and parent.
Mrs Bigmouth’s seven-word DVD review: Cloverfield
Like watching someone else play a videogame.
Related
18 thoughts on “Mrs Bigmouth’s seven-word DVD review: Cloverfield”
mupwangle says:
I quite liked it.
Alex says:
I thought it was excellent, though it was (oddly) better on a smaller screen than on a large one. I’m starting to think that it would be even better watched through the view finder of a camcorder. If ever there was a film suited to a tiny screen, Cloverfield is it.
Gary says:
I was bored to tears. Gave up after about half an hour.
I finally saw Transformers on Friday, and thought it was brilliant.
Gary says:
It is. As I said way back when: “It was a load of old rubbish, basically, and I enjoyed it immensely :)”
Dom says:
Cloverfield is a great film!
Pay particular attention to the very last scene – the scene where they’re on the carosel, and they’re running out of battery on the camera right before Beth says “I had a good day”. Just as the camera warning beep sounds (sounds like a watch alarm) you can see an onbect in the distance crashing into the sea…
> Cloverfield is a great film!
Pay particular attention to the very last scene
OK, now I’m definitely never going to watch it. Someone gave me that exact same advice about The Blair Witch Project, without which I’d have happily walked out after a few minutes. And the last scene, when it finally and boringly arrived, did nothing whatsoever to change the fact that it really was the worst film ever made.
Alex says:
That’s right Jo, make a judgement based on not seeing the actual movie!! ;)
mupwangle says:
Have to admit that I didn’t notice the last scene at all.
I can’t be arsed with all the “lost” type crap. That’s why I stopped watching lost too.
You know, Peter Greenaway built his career on that sort of stuff. Which is why the British film industry was dead for twenty years.
Dom says:
Well if it makes you happ (which from the sounds of things, it wont) the creators of Lost have got it all sussed out now. There’s none of that “making it up as they go along” stuff any more.
Anyways, Lost is good too, even if they did spend two seasons just idling along…
Mupwangle says:
>>I finally saw Transformers on Friday, and thought it was brilliant.
I think that, out of all the films I’ve seen recently, that Ironman is still the most entertaining. However, I thought that Transformers was going to be a normal action movie, but thought that it was suprisingly funny and very enjoyable. There are some real laugh out loud moments.
Having now watched cloverfield a second time (we had visitors who wanted to see it!) after knowing the “really clever”JJ Abrams backstory – it’s a much better film if you don’t know the backstory. Knowing the other shite actually makes it not worth watching at all.
I was expecting it to be more OTT, whereas in fact it is often completely disgusting, but never at the expense of realism. And it’s just a scarily accurate portrayal of parenthood, both impending and actual.
I quite liked it.
I thought it was excellent, though it was (oddly) better on a smaller screen than on a large one. I’m starting to think that it would be even better watched through the view finder of a camcorder. If ever there was a film suited to a tiny screen, Cloverfield is it.
I was bored to tears. Gave up after about half an hour.
I finally saw Transformers on Friday, and thought it was brilliant.
It is. As I said way back when: “It was a load of old rubbish, basically, and I enjoyed it immensely :)”
Cloverfield is a great film!
Pay particular attention to the very last scene – the scene where they’re on the carosel, and they’re running out of battery on the camera right before Beth says “I had a good day”. Just as the camera warning beep sounds (sounds like a watch alarm) you can see an onbect in the distance crashing into the sea…
Also, check out http://www.slusho.jp (and pay attention to the t-shirts some of them are wearing at the goiing-away party) and also http://www.1-18-08.com as well.
If all of that confuses you, then read the comments on this page:
http://www.filmstalker.co.uk/archives/2008/01/secret_hidden_in_cloverfield_e.html
It’s a very long-winded read, but you’ll see why I thought the film was so good after reading some of the comments.
:) :)
> Cloverfield is a great film!
Pay particular attention to the very last scene
OK, now I’m definitely never going to watch it. Someone gave me that exact same advice about The Blair Witch Project, without which I’d have happily walked out after a few minutes. And the last scene, when it finally and boringly arrived, did nothing whatsoever to change the fact that it really was the worst film ever made.
That’s right Jo, make a judgement based on not seeing the actual movie!! ;)
Have to admit that I didn’t notice the last scene at all.
I can’t be arsed with all the “lost” type crap. That’s why I stopped watching lost too.
> make a judgement based on not seeing the actual movie
The judgment I’m making is whether or not to see the movie. If I’d seen it, I wouldn’t be making it. Obviously.
> I can’t be arsed with all the “lost” type crap. That’s why I stopped watching lost too.
Yeah, same here. That, and the feeling the writers were making shit up as they went along.
You know, Peter Greenaway built his career on that sort of stuff. Which is why the British film industry was dead for twenty years.
Well if it makes you happ (which from the sounds of things, it wont) the creators of Lost have got it all sussed out now. There’s none of that “making it up as they go along” stuff any more.
Anyways, Lost is good too, even if they did spend two seasons just idling along…
>>I finally saw Transformers on Friday, and thought it was brilliant.
I think that, out of all the films I’ve seen recently, that Ironman is still the most entertaining. However, I thought that Transformers was going to be a normal action movie, but thought that it was suprisingly funny and very enjoyable. There are some real laugh out loud moments.
Having now watched cloverfield a second time (we had visitors who wanted to see it!) after knowing the “really clever”JJ Abrams backstory – it’s a much better film if you don’t know the backstory. Knowing the other shite actually makes it not worth watching at all.
> out of all the films I’ve seen recently, that Ironman is still the most entertaining.
Spot the non-parent. If it’s not out on DVD, it doesn’t exist, as far as Im concerned.
I just watched Knocked Up for the second time last night. It is utterly superb. Best film about having a baby ever.
We finally got round to watching that this weekend. Not what I expected – it was really rather sweet.
Yeah, I thought it was going to be more american pie.
I was expecting it to be more OTT, whereas in fact it is often completely disgusting, but never at the expense of realism. And it’s just a scarily accurate portrayal of parenthood, both impending and actual.