I like Michael Marshall, and his blog post about the other side of the piracy debate is worth your time. Not all anti-piracy sentiment comes from swivel-eyed loons or Disney.
The government is supposed to be on the side of laws, isnâ€™t it? Copyright is a law too. If they donâ€™t defend that law in the new kind of social space that the internet represents, where will the laxity end? What other laws will be let slide on the grounds that they might impede the rights of Internet users to do what the heck they feel like? What about your right to privacy? You care a lot about that one, donâ€™t you? What makes it so desperately important for the government to defend your rights there, but not defend othersâ€™ rights to be paid for their intellectual property?